About the index
A dated, sourced list of the decisions that made big tech services worse for the people using them. Not a ranking, not a rant, just the receipts.
"Enshittification" is Cory Doctorow's word for the way platforms go off: good to their users first, then good to their business customers at the users' expense, then good only to themselves. Everyone's watched it happen. This is the paper trail, one change at a time, so the next time someone asks when YouTube started blocking ad blockers, the answer comes with a date and a link.
What goes in
A decision by the company that made the service worse for its users: one of price rise, ads, paywall, removed feature, api restriction, tracking, lock-out, bricked, ai pushed in. Climbdowns and ended tests stay in, drawn hollow, because they still happened. Changes for the better don't, unless they undo one of ours.
How an entry is made
- Every entry is written from the source itself, never from memory or a search summary.
- The company's own post, help page or filing comes first. Decent press fills in when there isn't one. A forum post, a "best of" list or another tracker is never the source of a fact.
- Each source carries a quote copied from the page and a copy saved in the Wayback Machine, so it can't quietly change underneath us.
- Every number in an entry has to turn up in one of its sources, and every price rise has to start from the price before it. Both are checked by a script on every change and again every week.
- Titles say what happened in plain words. The opinions live on this page, not in the entries.
What it isn't
It isn't a score. With a handful of entries per service, any total would rank how much has been written about each company rather than how much worse it got. The marks on the wall are what's been logged, not how bad anything was. The price league is the one ranking, because prices are numbers nobody here made up.
Who's behind it
It's an open project on GitHub, kept up by a small team and anyone who fancies helping. No ads, no affiliate links, no tracking beyond a cookie-free visitor count. It'd be a bit rich otherwise.